Testing/Provoking Behavior

Coyotes “test” in order to assess and learn about the world around them. “Testing” needs to be differentiated from “messaging”. The messaging behavior, as I’ve often said, is a clear warning, usually to dogs, to keep away or go away. It involves scary posturing, including an arched back, gaping with lips pulled back and teeth bared, tail tucked under: the message is “leave!” If you encounter this behavior, the best thing to do is walk away and keep walking away. That’s what the coyote wants, so you might as well do it.

On the other hand, curious coyotes may *test* or *assess* how a dog will react to them which is not a demand to immediately move away — though this is what you should do practically to discourage the behavior. A coyote may test or assess a dog by approaching with a little bouncy gait or play-bows and try to interact, touch, or nip the dog’s tail. Some people have mistaken this for an invitation to play, whereas other dog owners have been terrified of any coyote approaching their dog. Although it does not look unfriendly, it needs to be discouraged. This is testing behavior and not play: a dog should be pulled away from this situation and walked away from the coyote. And here is the video, taken long ago in the San Francisco fog, which shows this coyote behavior towards, in this case, a disinterested dog who doesn’t react at all to the coyote. Few dogs will behave like this dog. Most dogs will lunge at and bark at the coyote.

A variation of this testing behavior might involve a bit of a dare or provocation — messaging displays are not involved. Your reaction should be the same: leash your dog and move away from the coyote showing him you aren’t interested in interacting. I’ll describe this here:

Coyotes watch in order to get to know the world. As they do so, they assess and judge situations and individuals of interest to them, in this case dogs. Watching informs them about what every animal is capable of and how their own safety might be affected by these capabilities. After watching for some time — maybe even weeks on a regular basis — a coyote might summon up enough courage to “test” or even “provoke” a reaction in a dog: it’s a variation on the testing behavior I outlined above.

One of the coyotes I watch has, for the last little while, stopped and fascinatingly watched a particular dog and his owner playing fetch on a large grassy field in a park. Over time, the coyote has come to know this dog’s capabilities and has now *graduated* to a mode where he either wants to *test* the situation or even *provoke* the dog into reacting to him. It’s not aggressive but it stirs things up a bit because it is an encounter that causes a response or retort. What is the coyote doing? First, he wants the dog to know he’s around and that this is his — the coyote’s — home. After all, the dog appears daily for less than an hour, whereas the coyote lives there.

It’s important to remember that only one coyote nuclear family occupies any one territory and all other coyotes are kept out. I’m sure this coyote exclusivity affects their feelings towards dogs. The coyote does this by entering into the dog’s field of vision and looking on or pretending to sniff something in the area, coming closer if the dog doesn’t react. To some, this may look like *play* and in fact it does border on play in that it’s fairly benign. The coyote will engage this way only only for a moment — just long enough to prove to himself that he’s the smarter and quicker and the more clever of the two. In other instances, I’ve seen the coyote swipe the dog’s ball and run off with it.

So the coyote heads towards the dog slowly. He pretends to do other things, including sniffing the ground. When the dog becomes aware of the coyote, the dog gives chase. The coyote runs off, just fast enough to keep out of reach of the dog, letting that dog get close enough so that he feels he might catch the coyote, even circling back so that the dog will continue. This, of course, only goes on for a minute before everyone yells at the dog owner to please leash his dog, which he does. That ends the interaction, and maybe in a week or so, it will happen again.

Below are photos of a coyote ducking and then crouching low in the ground to keep from being seen by a dog — this is their normal reaction to active dogs. Testing is reserved for dogs that they think pose no threat to them.

I myself, and several other people I’ve spoken to, have encountered a similar type of behavior towards human. In my case, it occurred because the coyote noticed I was focused on him: he wanted to asses what my intentions were: https://coyoteyipps.com/2023/11/03/testing-feints-and-zoomies/

© All information and photos in my postings come from my own original and first-hand observations and documentation work which I am happy to share, with permission and with properly displayed credit: ©janetkessler/coyoteyipps.com.

Mom Calling, No Answer

It was dark, so I couldn’t see anything, but I heard the vocalization loud and clear: a coyote was calling out to someone and there was no response, a snippet of which I’ve embedded here. I know the voice, and when I got home, by lightening the video, I was able to confirm visually that this was Mom.

Two weeks ago, Mom and her family left her usual hangout area in this section of her territory where I was now hearing her calling. Last year she also had moved in order to have her pups in a safer area. Note that this is still within her 2.5 square mile territory, it’s just a different hub of that territory. The wooded area she left here has been continuously cleared by the San Francisco Park Department irregardless of the habitat needs of our wildlife, in particular coyotes. What appears to matter to them is *what they think should live here*: i.e., native plants. The problem being that this area was all sand dunes long ago, and the few native plants that grew here were small desert type plants that provide no real habitat protection, especially from the many off-leash dogs who like chasing and antagonizing the coyotes. Dogs are an invasive, non-native species for which the coyotes need thicker cover for protection than what native species can offer. The sheer number of dogs in the city is overwhelming. The coyotes used to use the thick, entangled undergrowth to hide in. I went over to the area being cleared: it’s mostly hidden from human view by the few trees they’ve left up as a sort of curtain. All that’s left is dead wood: so this is probably the reason for moving. Note that “mating for life” I’m finding to be less and less true these days. This alpha female is on her fourth mate.

Mom

So Mom moved her family, along with her new mate and two yearlings. One *pup* — not quite a year old yet — can still occasionally be seen here alone: I don’t know if he chose to remain behind or if he was *assigned* to remain here: both ideas have occurred to me as possibilities, but there’s no way for me to know this. This youngster is a relatively large male, and I can imagine that Mom’s new mate might not want him around: I say this because of the bite marks I’ve seen on his snout the last few times I’ve seen him. Coyotes discipline, convey dislike, AND show dominance by grabbing another’s snout, sometimes quite hard.

Mom herself went through a family makeover earlier this year. First of all, her mate from over the past several years left her. Well . . . did he leave her or was he driven out? Again, I don’t know the answer, but either way, I found him happily paired up with another female on her territory about a mile away: it was such a surprise because coyotes have famous reputations for mating for life. It might be interesting for all to know that, as far as I have seen, it’s the females who choose (or inherit) their territories, and who also choose their specific den sites. Did he leave of his own volition, or was he driven out by her? I think the former, but I can’t prove it.

Then, last night, Mom was back here, definitely calling someone from her family. The calling went on for ten straight minutes: I’ve cut out a short section of it for you to hear. Who was she calling to? It could have been the large male pup who has been hanging out here alone, only he was not around last night. But, might she have been calling her old mate? Maybe his departure had not been a fait accompli? Maybe she was hoping he hadn’t left? Then again, maybe she was looking for her new mate who might have wandered off? I haven’t seen any of them since they left except 11-month old son. And then a few days ago I heard this definite calling out with no response on March 14th.

“don’t feed the coyotes”: new screening date

UPDATE: This movie can now be streamed on waterbear: https://www.waterbear.com/watch/dont-feed-the-coyotes.

If you live in San Francisco and missed this film the first time around, it will be showing again on March 26th, at the Bernal Branch Library in San Francisco, along with a Q&A afterwards with me and the filmmaker, Nick Stone-Schearer. You’ll need to reserve a space for yourself at Eventbrite. This is sponsored by the Bernal Heights Outdoor Cinema. Below is the same introduction they have on their site: https://bhoutdoorcine.org/f2f-3-26-24/

In the early 1900s, California paid a $5 bounty for dead coyotes as well as other predators. This practice and rapidly growing urban areas led to coyotes disappearing across the state. Over the next century, public sentiment towards wildlife slowly shifted. By the early 2000s, coyotes began appearing in the state including returning to San Francisco’s green spaces like Golden Gate Park, Bernal Hill and other parks and forests.

DON’T FEED THE COYOTES observes several years in the life of a three year-old coyote as she vies with a territorial challenger in the quest to form a family. Studied by two naturalists with different approaches and perspectives, we follow the coyotes as they journey in the city’s parks including Bernal Hill.

Join Nick Stone Schearer, director, and Janet Kessler, featured naturalist for a post-screening Q&A

Filmmaker, Nick Stone Schearer, began his filmmaking career in 2010 documenting the impacts of the BP oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. After graduating from the University of Wisconsin, he spent several years working and learning in New York before moving to the Bay Area in 2015, where he has focused on stories about the natural systems around us and the spectrum of relationships we have with them. Nick continues to collaborate with other filmmakers, organizations, and brands including Bloomberg, Netflix and the Biden/Harris campaign. He is currently working on a project about California newts.

Janet Kessler, known throughout San Francisco as “the Coyote Lady,” is a self-taught naturalist who is into her 16th year of daily field-research: documenting urban coyote behavior and family life — including their behavior with people and pets. Through her blog, coyoteyipps.com. Janet shares her observations, photos and guidelines for easy coexistence. Janet has a degree in Cultural Anthropology and a Masters in Art History from the University of Texas at Austin. She was born in South America and spent her childhood there. She has worked at Vorpal Gallery, at U.S.News & World Report, and at several law offices.

Raptor Resource Project: Guest Blog

This bird camera caught the sounds of coyotes, but only showed the eagles. Amy at the Raptor Resource Center asked if I would write something about coyote vocalizations for their blog and possibly general coyote behavior at this time of the year, and this is what I wrote: Press on the embedded title to read the article. This is an “in a nutshell” short summary piece! Thank you, Amy, for the invitation to write this!!

Tali Caspi’s Diet Study in SFGate!

To read more in SF Gate, with more of my photos, go to: https://www.sfgate.com/local/article/urban-coyote-diets-san-francisco-18703009.php

Tali wrote her own introduction to her study for this blog almost two months ago: https://coyoteyipps.com/2024/01/20/using-dna-in-scat-to-study-coyote-diet-by-tali-caspi/

More photos of coyote eating habits in San Francisco: https://coyoteyipps.com/urbancoyotesquared-gallery-of-urban-coyote-life/coyote-eating-habits-in-san-francisco-gallery/

Accepting Challenges and Adapting, by Walkaboutlou

Hello Janet!

As winter ends and Spring is upon us, change is the theme of the season. Some areas already have spring blossoms. Some areas are locked in snow. We continue on.

Profound changes in local coyote admittedly bothered me some..but I’ve accepted the changes and will keep adapting just like coyote. They have adapted for millennia beyond sucessful.

The changes are both small and huge. Im sure I don’t even get a fraction of it usually.

My dogs and I patrol, inspect and check on vast properties and areas. We note anything worth noting. We scout, track, study and immerse ourselves in the land. This is the 1st late winter that local coyote…have been relatively silent. Not mute. But definitely low key and subdued. 

The reason is…wolves. Wolves have very slowly…in trickles..resettled our region. Historically…my pack and I encountered coyote weekly especially in our pre dawn patrols. We developed strategies to counter coyote and give them options and room as we passed. The past 10 years the pack has grown very skillful in minimizing coyote encounters. It was par course to hear coyote concerts, insults and messages.

This has mostly…stopped. On ranch after ranch, range after range…we see changed coyote. They ARE NOT wiped out. But definelty reduced. Our area had a free flow of very vocal packs..sometimes numbering 4-7. 

We are now experiencing duos or 3 maybe. And they are quick to call and disappear. They are here…and leave scats still proclaiming territory. But they aren’t advertising visually. If they see or sense canines…they literally disappear in silence. It’s profound for us who always heard some tips or calls or canoe defiance…and recognition.

Most people don’t realize the sheer influence and power of wolves. They are doing what coyote do…surviving. They are actually much shyer, and quieter, then coyote. Less daring. But….when it comes to canine hierarchy..wolves are top dogs in woods. A lone nomadic wolf trots thru and is gone. A territorial pack of wolves methodically, regularly, patrols vast vast areas. They need to eat. And they will run off…or dispatch, any strange wolf, coyote or dog they find in territory. We have 2 regional packs minimally..vying for vast areas. They travel further and faster then any coyote…rountinely. 

The result is..after a few years..wolf wary coyote behaviors we’ve never known.

If we want wilderness and wildlife..this is the other side. Animals will establish themselves. They will survive. And some species are more direct about it. 

The coyote aren’t wiped out..but no doubt…many have not survived once wolves claim the foothills to cascade circuits. It is nature.

I admit my own struggle with it. Areas the pack and I used to hear coyote neighbors…silent. Also..its humbling. My pack and local coyote established a specific..somewhat sloppy truce. A lot of growls and messages…and distance. 

Wolves are inherently shy of humans. I’m not going to hear them yip to my pack. But..my pack also can’t counter wolves as they did coyote. 

The Wolves are here and no canines can contest that.

The coyote get quieter and more low key. My dogs stick close to me and we go fwd. We are adapting to wolves. Acknowledging wolves. And amazed to live with Wolves. Real…horizon roaming wolves.

But I miss my noisy coyote. 

Take care..

Lou