Coyote Intelligence

Coyote captures prey in a park nestled within a densely human populated city

Anyone tuned-in to coyotes over any length of time will become aware of how highly intelligent they are. If intelligence is defined as “the ability to acquire and apply knowledge and skills,” then coyotes demonstrate it in abundance through their ability to adapt, their perceptiveness, and their ability to meet and solve challenges. I put this posting together because, although I have always accepted their intelligence, I hadn’t thought about it in a cohesive way until a CBS interviewer put the question to me: “Tell me about their intelligence”. So here it is.

Their intelligence begins with their highly refined senses: vision, acute hearing, and most notably, smell — and remember that each of these is connected to highly developed areas of the brain that can finely interpret these. They are able to gather nuanced information and then finely manipulate, organize and remember that information for their own needs. If you look it up, you’ll find that a coyote’s olfactory lobe is more than twice the size of a domestic dog’s, enabling them to interpret a world saturated in scent. Smelling helps them detect threats, find mates, recognize rivals, *map* their territories, and accurately navigate their territories and beyond.

Please keep cats indoors: it’s a given, and not shocking, that they will opportunistically grab cats if circumstances are are right. Coyotes are both predator and prey, so they are always suspicious and looking over their shoulder for trouble, particularly from dogs, and ready to react.

Coyotes are generalists—just like us humans. Our species thrives not by fitting into a single ecological niche, but by adapting flexibly to many. Coyotes share this capacity: they can live in all climates from the coldest north to the hottest deserts; from arid desert to beach to mountain to riparian terrains, and among all levels of human population density, from ranches to city parks, to our densest neighborhoods. They are both predator and prey, which means they must think like both at the same time: they hunt in a dominant fashion, and at the same time they are continuously highly-suspicious of being hunted. In wilder areas, wolves, large cats and humans kill them. So they keep defensively aware of their surroundings and everything in it. As Jake Breeden put it: “Wolves and humans stride across landscapes as if they own a place, whereas coyotes slink, pause, and dart because they’ve seldom owned anything—except their ability to read the room.” Coyotes are always reading their environment—always strategizing and planning ahead.

Their GPS: They Absorb and Understand the Lay-of-the-Land and the Situations On It

They are great at mapping spaces and situations and have amazing memories for this

Coyotes are incredibly aware of the land — I call it their GPS system — and the situations thereon. They understand not just the geography, but the dynamic situations on those geographical locations which they move through. In San Francisco, for example, within their 2.5 square mile territories, they have a detailed understanding and memory not only for where everything is and how safe it is for them: parks, corridors, food sources, safe street crossings, and risky dog routes—but also that the dynamics of those areas change over the duration of a day and over longer periods of time. 

Dogs are their chief nemesis in cities, but they have to watch out for ravens and crows and all corvids, and cars are their chief killers in urban areas.

They also remember meaningfully. Unlike humans, who often need notes to recall things, coyotes store what’s relevant: feeding spots, threatening individuals, the sound and appearance of specific cars, the daily rhythm of traffic, and even when spigots are turned on and can be relied on for water.

LEARNING: Curiosity and Dealing with Challenges: They Learn and Change by Watching and Trying

Coyotes are fast learners, mostly by observing and imitating. Sometimes it takes only two exposures—or fewer—for a coyote to remember which car feeds them, and where. I’ve seen them watch dogs dig to catch a gopher — when the dog leaves empty-handed, they hurry over to the excavated spot, having less work to do now. I’ve seen them spy on a a sibling burying food and then steal it and bury it somewhere else just for themselves. I read that they’ve watched humans unlatch gates and then attempted the same. They learn when it’s safe to cross roads, often looking both ways as they’ve seen humans and other coyotes do, and even use the traffic light to help them get across. They can adjust to changing conditions: so for example, when prey becomes scarce, they switch to berries or insects. They adapt by creatively trying something new and different. Lou has written about a lone coyote who, in the absence of regular rodent prey, has switched to crayfish fishing as the major part of his diet!!

Eating blackberries when prey is less plentiful and Crossing the Street with the light at a crosswalk.

You can read about cognitive tests where coyotes outperform domestic dogs in independent problem-solving, persistence, and creativity. Dogs are intimately connected to humans — the two have evolved together over thousands of years, so dogs look to humans for guidance, whereas coyotes think for themselves. This independent intelligence makes them wildly unsuitable as pets—but supremely equipped for survival.

I’ve seen them engage in purposeful deception: leading people or dogs away from dens, vocalizing from false locations to protect pups. I’ve also seen them *pretend* to be hunting in the distance when in fact they are assessing the threat from a dog or even a human. Deception requires insight, forward planning, and an ability to mentally model another’s perspective.

HIGHLY SOCIAL: Family Life is Immensely Interactive, Organized and Communicative

Communication through vocalization, eye-contact and body language, family life, hierarchy and care through mutual grooming are tantamount to their survival.

Coyotes live in families and form long-lasting bonds. They constantly interact interpersonally and have individual relationships with each other. They can *read* each other, and they communicate constantly using a variety of vocalizations —howls, yips, growls, whines, squeals, hisses, and much more —modulated with tongue, lips, pitch, and tone. They use these to express their feelings and intentions towards each other, as warnings, to *check in* and call to other family members over great distances, and to define themselves to any neighboring coyotes. They also rely on more silent forms of communication involving body language and facial expressions, which even we humans can sometimes interpret. By watching them carefully, it becomes obvious that their finely nuanced communication is complex and intentional. Their constant interactions reinforce hierarchy, cooperation, and cohesion within families.

Scent-marking is another key form of communication: they use it to define and and reinforce territorial boundaries through urine scent marking, the same way we use fences. But it’s also through smell that they can detect injury in each other and in other species which helps with their hunting. They primarily identify outsiders — along with their personal information such as gender, social status, health — through their odors.

Coyotes recognize individuals: not only within their species, of course, but across species. They can distinguish particular dogs, cars, and even humans—far more reliably than most people can identify individual coyotes. And, by the way, ravens who are also highly intelligent and social can do the same — they can identify individual humans, even though we can’t tell THEM apart!

PLAY: They Play Creatively and Invent Games

Coyotes play and entertain themselves constantly!

Coyotes aren’t just practical. They play constantly! They tease and horse around, they invent games with sticks, balls, and found objects. They seem to like and be energized by novelty and dealing with it, and even by humor. Their play demonstrates creativity and imagination—they know the difference between “just for fun” and “for real.”

They plan ahead: choosing rendezvous spots and returning to favored hangout spots. Their actions show intentionality, not just instinct. In fact, it appears that planning is involved in a good deal of their activities. Have you ever seen a coyote trotting down the street? It’s not random: they know exactly where they are going and what they are doing — it’s planned out.

SURVIVORS: Evolving and Adapting in Response to Human Pressures

Coyotes have large neocortices—the outer brain layer associated with higher-level functions such as reasoning, learning, and decision-making. This helps explain their capacity for adaptation and behavioral plasticity. They think, observe, experiment, and remember—because they must. Survival demands intelligence.[Wikipedia]

Their intelligence is not like a human’s—after all, they have different bodies with different capacities, capabilities, and different needs, but it’s real, and robust, and magically suited to the world they inhabit. Despite constant persecution by humans (hunters and even our own government kills hundreds of thousands of coyotes every year), coyotes have expanded their range throughout the northern continent. In many places, their numbers are actually highest where they are hunted the hardest. They don’t just survive. They outsmart.

And perhaps that, more than anything, is why some humans dislike them: because they don’t yield, don’t disappear, and don’t conform. They adapt—and they persist.

Denning Challenges and Choices. And Good Moms. By Walkaboutlou

Hi Janet, 

I wanted to share with you a student’s observations and leanings. Which lead to more questions. 

Kinky Tail continues to raise her very active litter. There are 7 now..so either there was a miscount originally or 2 have disappeared. They think 2 pups have disappeared because there is a local golden eagle who for years has been seen with coyote pups, fox kits and feral cats. It seasonally comes to this area during lambing and calving times. It has been seen daily flying over den areas.

That well may have encouraged Kinky to move pups as well as..ticks. Locally we’ve seen plague level numbers of ticks. And Kinkys grooming times with pups seemed very long last week. Her last den area was absolutely infested with 3 species of ticks. Ugh.

Now however, Kinky moved pups to a rendezvous of log piles, poison oak bushes, and grazing cattle. 

The student says she doesn’t believe the location was randomly picked. 

The abundance of poison oak keeps people out except rarely riders of horse or quads passing thru. Ranch folk.  

The grazed range grass is short and doesn’t hold high tick densities compared with long grasses or brush areas. 

And finally, having an entire cow to scavenge 2 miles away after move means less animals near pups (scavengers galore) and Kinky doesn’t have to hunt the longer grass fields for voles. Which mean tick pick up. She has the cow or many dozens of caches. Also discovered was she visits an orchard and gleans old fallen Apple’s from last Fall.

This Student feels Kinky’s choice of den was premeditated and thought carefully out. It has minimal tick numbers. Humans rarely come and pass quickly. It’s open with vast vistas and hillsides yet has hiding places for pups. The Longhorns don’t encourage canine visitors. It’s close to dead cow but far enough pups don’t meet scavengers.

She also is study wild turkey brood site selections and says the studies lend to each other. Wild Turkey Hens need to sit on eggs around 28 days. The picked site is obviously paramount. A poorly picked site is disastrous. There are hens that pick poorly or lose patience or dedication and leave eggs too long as well. Then there are hens that cover eggs while minimally foraging for bugs and food and rush back fast. How a Hen Broods means Everything. And not all hens are good moms. 

She says it’s same for Coyote. Some mothers are functional but rather minimal. Or make bad choices. Some..seem to be absolutely dedicated mothers. She feels most coyote are very dedicated Moms. 

So how much is choice and thought when picking a site to hide and raise your kids? She feels Kinky Tail is neighborhood cognizant. 

In her words “No wolf gang signs. No noisy dog parties. No bad nosy people. Riding thru people that she’s known since pup and plenty of longhorns and poison oak seem the latest mood and pic”

Kinky is doing well. She has 7 very active very fat pups. She’s busy busy busy. By day she stays at den. At night it’s cow scavenging, cow caches and long long drinks. And some nights old apples. She grooms her pups even as she comes home bedraggled. Growls briefly but playfully at Mate as he leaves for day shift. 

Real Estate Realities are working out for Kinky. 

Lou

Old Habits, by Walkaboutlou

Hi Janet.

Kinky Tail moved her litter again and it reminded us of her Father’s moves and habits. 

Her father in times of vulnerability and old age sought the company of a captive herd of bison. He not only found the stirred up voles easy meals..the bison seemed to keep canines away. 

Kinky Tail’s observers feel she’s nervous more so with pups starting to dodder about. She moved them to a hilly area with cut wood piles…and smack dab in Longhorn pastures. These are range cattle held temporarily as they calve or get checked on. They aren’t afraid of wolves, bear, cougar…arent really fans of dogs but pretty much ignore coyote. 

With such neighbors she can still easily go and scavenge her dead cow as live ones provide horned deterrents to any predators or dogs that pass close to her pup dens. 

It could be coincidence. But it sure seems like her father’s moves. His last few vulnerable months were always with Bison. 

2nd pic…white bull….pile of logs is one of the puppy dens. 

Horns work!

Lou 

Kinky and her Mate can move here and cattle won’t even look up. If a dog or wolf trotted thru, different story. 

Personalities Emerge Early

rough and tumble and playful

rough and tumble — they’re playful

There’s an array of trait possibilities which form our personalities and make each of us unique. This is as true for animals as it is for humans. Pet owners will tell you that dogs from the same litter can differ tremendously: each pup brings its own unique combination of characteristics into the world.

And coyotes, too, are unique individuals.  I’ve seen this particular litter three times now and I’m seeing behavioral differences which distinguish each pup.

The top photo shows pups who are rough and tumble and full of play. They like to run pell mell after each other — tumbling over each other and getting all tangled up is part of the fun.

reserved and careful and even a little bit dainty

Diametrically opposed is a very little reserved and careful pup. This one sat back and watched as the others roughhouse and play fearlessly. When she noticed me, she hid behind a tree. She? Of course I don’t know, but that would be my guess based on her comparative smallness and daintiness. I wonder if she is a runt.

the adventurer

the adventurer

And then, there’s the adventurer who is curious and explores far-off distances alone — probably unbeknownst to his parents who are still trying to keep the pups’ existence a secret.

I’ve caught him — he stands out as being larger and stronger than the others — on my field camera not anywhere near where I’ve seen the others: exploring and examining the territory, totally on his own.

I’ve also spotted this one sleeping on his own out in the open, which is something his parents do, but not his siblings. This one seems to be exceptionally bright, inquisitive, and self-sufficient — at least comparatively. Just hope he doesn’t get himself into trouble early on by wandering so far off from the rest of them in this litter.

The Wayward Puppy, by Charles Wood

Pup Goes Forward

Pup Goes Forward

These pictures are of Dad escorting his puppies in June 2010. He saw me, perceived me as a threat, and stopped. Although not all are pictured, he had at least three puppies with him.

One of the puppies didn’t stop when Dad stopped. Instead it got ahead of him and paused briefly. “One Pup Gets Forward” has the wayward puppy partially concealed in the lower left. Then the wayward puppy went forward, kept going, and got well out of Dad’s reach many yards away.

Dad did not follow the wayward puppy. “Dad Can’t Follow It” pictures Dad angry because one of his puppies got away. A different puppy clings to Dad.

Dad retreated with the rest of the puppies. Way too late for my comfort, the wayward puppy galloped back and caught up with Dad. I’ve never since seen a cute little coyote puppy run that fast. It was galloping as fast as a rocket, so earnestly wanting to be with Dad. I was ecstatic. I had again been able to take pictures of a coyote father with his puppies.

Dad Stops

Dad Stops

When I returned home I studied the photographs and also studied photographs taken on previous days. My study led me to some conclusions.

Generally Dad is cautious and expects danger when walking around. When Dad perceives a threat he makes an assessment and then takes action. With puppies in tow, Dad has fewer choices of action. Puppies are rambunctious and take effort to control. With puppies and perceiving a threat, there isn’t much Dad can effectively do other than to collect them and retreat.

Usually when they all came across me, the puppies noticed when Dad stopped and became cautious too. Cautious, the puppies held still, went to Dad, to each other, hid, or went back in the direction they all came from. The puppies were also curious and looked in my direction to see what Dad’s fuss was all about. When all were somewhat settled, Dad led a retreat. Note that with puppies, when Dad perceives a threat he expects good behavior from his children and usually gets it.

Dad Leaves To Protect Other

Dad Leaves To Protect Other

Unfortunately, this time one of the puppies didn’t get the “caution” message. One puppy kept going forward alone, getting somewhat far away. Initially it stopped, but it wanted to keep going and it did! This time Dad’s circumstances weren’t usual because he had a very poorly behaving puppy!

Yet Dad has situational intelligence and so do I. As I studied the photographs, I thought Dad had to understand that he couldn’t be in two places at the same time. Indeed, he looked toward the wayward puppy and appeared to be stymied, exasperated, resigned, composed, in charge, and as if saying: “I told you to stop.” Then Dad, still looking in charge, lifted his head toward me, the cause of his dilemma.

Dad Can't Follow It

Dad Can’t Follow It

After studying the pictures, I realized just how angry Dad was. Why? It hit me and I was stunned by the thought. Dad was angry with me for separating out a puppy and he was angry because he couldn’t protect them all. In his mind, I had intended to cull one of his young. In my mind, I was but only watching a show. In Dad’s mind, I had won and he had lost a lot. He carried that look of frustrated hatred, a look that comes with a defeat.

In Dad’s mind, one puppy was beyond his protection, liable to be taken by a predator. I think he knew the situation required him to sacrifice one puppy for the safety of the others. Dad couldn’t protect the rest of his flock if he went to help one vulnerable puppy. He loves all his puppies and that day Dad knew he had to let one go. I caused it and Dad was livid. Yet he accepted the situation and acted prudently. Dad offered one of his children up so he could protect the rest. Until I arrived home to excitedly review my pictures, I thought I had been watching a show complete with cute puppies. At home with the photographs, I felt remorse. It wasn’t a show. To Dad, it was as real as life gets, life for which he strives to prepare his young.

Posting written by Charles Wood. Visit Charles Wood’s website for more coyote photos: Charles Wood. His work is copyrighted and may only be used with his explicit permission.

Following Mom, by Charles Wood

Pup1

Both photographs are of my LA county pup following Mom around. Both were alarmed when they saw my companions, another human and two good sized dogs, and me. Mom headed down the road and within a minute her puppy followed. The road offered us a clear view of them, but for only parts of the way because brush along the road at times concealed them from view. Soon both coyotes were hidden. Yet Mom could have immediately hid with her puppy in the brush. Why didn’t she? I think she had decided it was to her advantage to use the road strategically.

When Mom took to the road, I didn’t know if she intended to approach or avoid. I think she knew that by taking to the road, I wouldn’t know where she would end up or whether she intended to come towards me or intended to go away. All I would really know was that she was on the move.

PupMom

After dusk, Mom came out from hiding to sit and stare at us, her puppy still in the brush. A third coyote, Dad, came in and out of view near them. Together, Mom and Dad formed a stone wall against an intrusion. Then, apparently instantly oblivious to danger, the puppy decided to come out and join Mom. Mom got up and the puppy followed her back into the brush. The puppy is too young to know that Mom doesn’t want to play when actively guarding the family.

Posting written by Charles Wood. Visit Charles Wood’s website for more coyote photos: Charles Wood. His work is copyrighted and may only be used with his explicit permission.

Communication And Intelligence, by Charles Wood

As a boy my friends and I talked as we rambled. Yet most of our communication was body language. We spoke about what we had just done. Talking contributed least to the communication. Most of our communication consisted of touching things and bumping and hitting each other. It was sublime. Dogs, wolves, and coyotes viscerally connect in the same way. Dogs and children instinctively know how to play together. They read each other’s constant motion. Each is physical and energetic.

My dogs jostle around together. They do focused sniffing, reading smells. Their vocalizations are infrequent declarations. They competitively pee. They alert when seeing rodents, ecstatic and wanting to chase. They stare up at treed squirrels for as long as I allow. If something moves elsewhere, they tell each other with gestures and barks. Never far from each other, they notice gait, posture, hesitations, head direction, tail position, every small change, and minutiae we will probably never see, smell or hear.

One night, I watched six dogs outside a dog park chase what at first appeared to be a cat. The dogs packed after the animal and treed it. They could have caught it. It was clear they didn’t want to. They didn’t even bother the animal when it was up in the tree. Chasing it, getting close to top speed, a quiver went through all the dogs. They pulled back just a enough. A flash of rump suggested they were chasing a bob cat. That information passed from dog to dog. The chase turned into a show. The dogs tried to conceal from their owners that they hadn’t done their best. Instead they had made a mock effort. There was face saving going on in that group that night. There was also a lot of palpable nonverbal communication.

I watched a documentary on wolves hunting deer. The humans were mystified. How did the wolves decide which of the deer to hunt? They studied the film. Eventually they saw that one of the deer was slightly lame. They agreed a human couldn’t easily see that tiny weakness in a running deer. The wolves spotted the deer’s injury. The decision by the wolves passed through the group in much the same way that those dogs each decided to not chase a bob cat. Canines are attuned to subtle variations in movement. Movement is rich with information and canines have excellent spatial intelligence.

For example, my dog Holtz remembers exactly where he saw cats while on our walks. He remembers regardless of when we last passed by. His demeanor anticipates arriving at a known cat’s range. I suspect Holtz has high value points mapped out. He zones in on an area when far from it, suggesting he relies on memory. For Holtz, a walk is a milk run with known special stops sprinkled along the way. He has also learned the local watering holes and drags me to them on our walks. On hot days he uses them to get soaked.

At a large park nearby, we always enter on the side opposite a ground squirrel colony. The colony is a quarter mile away and over a hill. Holtz has little interest going anywhere except the colony. A mile from the park, while walking along a street parallel to it, he tries at every cross street to go there. I don’t doubt he could travel alone from our house to the colony four miles away. It is a place he sees in his mind’s eye. He has a mental map to the park. It is a place remembered as opposed to one merely in his sight. Would he get the idea to go there alone? I don’t know, but he can form intent.

Holtz

I observed Holtz act with situational intelligence at a dog beach. We were there with Lucas, his German Shepherd buddy. Holtz was off leash romping and I was working hard to control Lucas with a leash. Holtz flew by, looked at us, and clearly had an idea. He bounced over and began herding Lucas. Holtz calmed Lucas down with body checks. I don’t know if Holtz’s idea was to help or to just have fun. Either way, he read the situation and resolved the conflict.

Dad

Another example of Holtz forming intent is his use of guile. He will pretend he wants to drink water from a stream so he can get off leash. Instead of getting a drink, he’ll run to a distant high value area. A more common example of canine guile is selective listening. In certain situations they pretend not to hear us yelling their names.

Holtz remembers interesting places and is able to form intent. He knows his way around. In cities, with reasonable restrictions on dogs, we may forget that country dogs roam and return home. In cities it is somewhat novel to see a dog out walking itself. “Out walking itself” is an odd phrase considering that walking around is what dogs do. Coyotes do it with such style I almost forget dogs are equally skilled.

Coyotes form intent, know interesting places, and remember them. With keen spatial intelligence they know their way around. They know where they are going and they know why. They seek food, water, information about their neighbors, safe resting spots, shade, warmth, and novelty. They make their rounds looking for intruders, making sure the doors are locked. They look for each other seeking companionship, family, play, and security for themselves and for their children. We see them out and about, exuding purposefulness. It is hard to exactly know their purpose on any particular occasion. It is safe to say their purposes aren’t significantly different from our own.

Posting written by Charles Wood. Visit Charles Wood’s website for these and more coyote photos: Charles Wood. His work is copyrighted and may only be used with his explicit permission.