Sibling Rivalry #4b: Bullied Three Consecutively Times Before Snapping

This is a continuation of the previous posting which left off with a dominant coyote remembering the prey it had abandoned.

The dominant coyote finds his prey, a vole, and eats it wholeheartedly as the more submissive coyote looks on — actually approaching within only a few inches.

When the submissive guy moves off, the dominant guy, again, for the third time within 20 minutes, approached the departing fellow and attempted dominating him again. This time the less dominant guy stood up for himself, snapping viciously at his bullying sibling.  The bully moved on out of the area, and the bullied fellow sat down and watched him leave.

It is sad to see the fun-loving, playful young coyotes becoming antagonistic and hierarchical. They must do so as they attain their adulthood. They may soon go their separate ways. A childhood chapter in their lives is closing, and a new life as independent adults is coming on. We are all waiting to see how this develops. But who knows? Maybe these coyotes will remain in the area as part of an intact pack. Maybe they are just establishing and tightening the social order. A firm and well defined social order may be needed for the group to operate smoothly.

Sibling Rivalry #1: Bullying and Snapping

These two young adult coyotes, 19 month olds, are almost always irritable and antagonistic in each other’s company these days. Although they still walk around together at times, they no long play-fight the way they used to: the contests have become real displays of put-downs and submission. One has become dominant over the other.  Almost always, the dominant one will approach the less dominant one to “lord it over him”. The response, ultimately, is for the less dominant one to flee, but his response also involves snapping, falling to the ground in submission and growling — I’ll show all these sequences in my next few postings. This sequence here involved an attempt to mount by the dominant one, and the accosted one then snapping and removing himself from the immediate vicinity of the dominant one.

Bullying And Dominance

Here is another instance of bullying and dominance between two 18-month old male coyote siblings: it has to do with coyote family dynamics. The dominant one rushes at the other with his hackles up and then pursues him aggressively. The other one runs off, crouches low, holds his ears back, and hits the ground. This trend continues on a stronger level than previously. Notice that at the end, the dominant coyote licks his chops: I’ve seen this before in this type of interaction and wonder what it means.

Intimidated Into The Bushes

Here is another instance of intimidation by one coyote over its sibling. I was watching the dominant coyote sibling when he spotted his sibling and approached hackles up. The less dominant coyote retreated into the bushes for protection. The dominant coyote went no further, but licked his chops and moved on, and that was the end of the spat. Both coyotes then continued their meanderings, but at a distance from each other.

Mom Teases & Tests

In this sequence of photographs, a mother coyote catches a vole and then seems to tease the younger coyote to come and get it. He does so, but when he actually latches on to the vole, the mother is right there and encloses the young coyote’s muzzle with hers — a sign of her dominance. The young coyote immediately withdraws. The mother again runs off with the vole and ultimately ends up eating it. But the younger coyote watches, and HE is the one in the last photo who is licking his chops!!  This sequence may be about a mother reconfirming her dominance to an offspring who has been showing signs of dominance towards one of its siblings.

Aggressor Wins The Ball

In the past, these two male siblings have always played rather casually. Their “play fighting”, always ended with two “winners” and the play session was always fun for both. Recently, the play fighting has turned more intense: it has become important for the more dominant one to win, which means that the other one “looses.”

In this sequence here, it is the less dominant coyote who found a frayed softball and took it off to chew on it. The other one came up, dominating the first one, and ended up taking the ball. The looser walked off defeated in the last photo. Notice in the photos that the aggressor was always on top or with the ball.

More and more, recently, I have seen the same aggressor coyote intrude on what the other one is doing and take over. We can all guess where this behavior is leading to and what the end result might be.

Mom Keeps Vigilant While Youngsters Play

There appear to be very definite get-together times and maybe even several get-together places for the members of a coyote family. These get-togethers happen after a period of separation and lone activity, and appear to occur at least once in the morning and once in the evening. These sessions begin with intense affectionate greetings, including lots of kisses, body contact, jumping around and very often squeals of delight. During these group times, the coyotes play and just enjoy each other’s company. They may hang out together to watch or monitor activity in a park. The session then ends with one and then two coyotes going off in their own direction — either to hunt alone or rest alone. I have seen the entire group go off together to another location to monitor or hunt, but eventually the individuals end up going their own individual ways.

During these meetings, while the younger coyotes are playing, their mom normally watches them. She is in charge. Life for 18 month-old pups is still carefree. They surrender all vigilance and control to Mom, whereas life for her consists of knowing everything there is to know about coyote existence. She keeps watch for them and is prepared to defend them. How long will this go on? It is my thought that as long as she is there for them, they will continue in this mode: “It is not until you have to pay the bills that you pay them.” The younger coyotes still have a pup’s existence which is carefree, fun and happy, and it includes lots of displays of affection. They can take care of themselves by hunting and fleeing from dogs, but they don’t seem to have the whole picture yet. These observations are the same ones made by Charles Wood in his posting  “Waiting” on September 4.

Mom very often seems to be gallivanting with the youngsters — she often is right in the middle of their activity. But upon closer examination, although she is there, she is not being rough and tumble or carefree at all. She soon tends to duck out from their activity and to sit off to the side to keep watch over their safety. They know this. Mom has her job to do, which involves being totally aware of the bigger picture. The younger ones are not there yet, even at 18 months of age.

Although the mother coyote normally just “watches” the younger ones, I have noticed her try to control the direction of their movements, attempting to lead them in a certain direction. Sometimes they respond right off, but sometimes she resigns herself to settling down until they are ready to come along with her. And sometimes she even abandons her effort and lets them handle themselves.

“Pursued”, by Charles Wood

Saturday I waited on the river bank for half an hour looking east.  I stood with my dog about 130 yards from the main north-south dirt road often used by my coyotes.  I neither saw nor heard anything until 7:40 pm when three coyotes exited the underpass trotting south into their main field.  Dad, in the rear, stopped several yards south of the underpass.  The other two continued their trot south.  Dad dropped scat and then hurriedly followed the other two coyotes.  Apparently all three were hurriedly returning from the area to the north, an approximately 100 acre sanctuary for animal and plant life.  Their main field is connected to the sanctuary by an underpass and I have previously observed both Mom and Dad in the sanctuary.  In contrast, my coyotes’ main field approximates 25 acres, where all except around six acres were mowed a month ago for weed abatement.  My coyotes numbered nine a week before the mowing:  Mom, Dad and seven pups.  Since then I’ve observed no more than four coyotes together at the same time in their field.

Dad caught up with the other two, having stopped to look behind him several times in the process.  Together, they all stopped to look north from where they had come.  I saw no pursuers.  Dad took a break to groom his mate.  A youngster was lying on the ground beneath them.  Dad finished grooming Mom and then bared his teeth at the youngster.  He stood over it, tongue out, as Mom went a bit to the north and stopped.  She looked both north and east down flat dirt roads.  Apparently pursuers could come from either north or east.  The youngster followed her, and then returned to Dad.  Dad put the returning youngster to the ground with seriously bared teeth.  The youngster then remained near Dad as Dad again checked north.  The youngster also stayed with Dad as he went to investigate some odors a few yards north of where Mom had stopped.  This investigation lasted about a minute.  It ended when the youngster headed south while Dad marked whatever they had discovered.  Mom and the youngster headed south and Dad followed.  While following, Dad frequently stopped and looked behind.

Mom and the youngster arrived at an entrance to what I assume is the area of dense brush that contains their den.  She marked the road and then she and the youngster disappeared into dense brush.  At that point I looked back down the dirt road for Dad and did not see him.  I waited a bit, saw no pursuers and decided the show was over for the evening.  I doubted that any vocalizations would follow because vocalizing didn’t seem wise in the circumstances.

What were the exact circumstances?  From whom did they flee?  Why was Mom groomed and the youngster instead chided?  The second time the youngster was disciplined seemed clearly to tell the youngster to remain near Dad.  What odor was important enough to give them pause to investigate and mark when obviously in flight?  Did the three return to join other family members?  How many of the other six children are still alive?

That the three were fleeing from one or more coyotes seems a safe bet.  Perhaps the grooming behavior performed on Mom by Dad was to calm and reassure her.  The youngster obviously had messed up earlier.  I say obviously because it had prostrated itself by the time Dad had caught up with them.  Had it handled an encounter with other coyotes poorly, or caused such an encounter?  After being disciplined it chose to head towards Mom and apparently for that, was disciplined again.

It seems safe to say the odor marked was that of a coyote trespasser.  The odor was important enough for both father and child to thoroughly absorb the information it contained.

The position Mom took, looking both north and east, suggests that no other of their family members were east.  The area to the east, consisting of about four lightly covered acres, has its own north-south entry point and another entry point at the east most boundary, not particularly safe from intruding coyotes.  The more southern area into which they ultimately disappeared is dense brush.  I have seen Mom alone similarly seeming pursued as she headed south.  She at that time also marked the point where she headed into that brush, nearly the same spot as this Saturday.  This southern area is about two acres and I can’t take a step there without cracking dry twigs or rattling brush.  Probably intruder coyotes would sound similar alarms.  The high ground, banks to surrounding road beds and structures, are planted with rows of reeds that are green and supple for being irrigated.  They are thick, high, and have tight yet navigable spaces for evasion and ambush.  I’m hoping the other youngsters can be left there unsupervised while Mom or Dad or both reconnoiter before taking more family members out for their early evening hunt.

I’ve read and heard many times that feces and urine mark territory and thought it rather benign, perhaps even thoughtful or polite.  I have rethought that.  I have seen Dad drop scat a few yards from me to begin a confrontation.  Dumping, scraping, mock charges and barking do drive me off, particularly with the way he looks so much larger with his fur buffed out.  It isn’t simply that he can drop scat.  He can do so and back it up with all his power.  To mark while fleeing, and to mark the area they have the most interest in defending suggests to me:  “Abandon hope all ye who enter here”.

Posting written by Charles Wood. Visit Charles Wood’s website for these and more coyote photos: Charles Wood. His work is copyrighted and may only be used with his explicit permission.

Submissive Behavior

Here is a sequence of photos showing a greeting between a mother coyote and her yearling offspring, a male. The full-grown pup is 17 months old. Not only is there plenty of affection, but the yearling shows very strong submissive behavior: coming in from below, constantly seeking mouth contact. Interestingly, each coyote appears to close its mouth over the other’s — but one does it from a crouched position. The mother is on the right-hand side in all of these photos.

Reconfirming Her “Status” or “Place in the Park” constitutes Communication, not Aggression

I’ve been studying urban coyote behavior for some time now, and I’ve seen a lot. I’ve also noticed people’s reactions to coyotes: these run from detestation and annoyance to joyous and enthralled. Those who have fears and are apprehensive, or who have had trouble with a coyote because of their own uncontrollable dogs, often have negative feelings about coyotes. At the opposite extreme are those who feel a strong personal tie to them. I’ve heard individuals say they “communed” with a coyote as they watched it for a little while, and I’ve overheard a number of people say a gentle “goodby” after having spent some time watching one!

Today I had someone ask me about “aggressive urban coyotes”. The language is not precise. Understanding what is going on requires more than just what meets the eye. “People often conflate the words “aggressive”, “assertive“, “bold”, “curious”, and “investigating” for example, and we need consistency so that we can come to a better understanding of how coyotes actually interact with humans” [“Coyotes: fascinating animals who should be appreciated and not killed” by Mark Bekoff, May 12, 2010 in Animal Behavior].

I have watched coyotes in our parks over time. I have not ever seen blatant “aggression”. I have seen a coyote “defend” itself when it was chased by a dog, and I have seen a coyote act defensively when it was surprised by a dog. I have seen a coyote become very “touchy” during pupping season — again, this is a self-protective and defensive reaction to dogs. People need to see the dog threat from the coyote’s point of view to understand what is going on. If a dog is threatening a coyote, or has in the past, the ground will have been laid, by their own dogs, for coyotes to now react antagonistically towards this same dog — this is a defensive reaction and communication to keep the dog away. Even an unruly leashed dog lunging towards a coyote within a short distance will be transmitting the same message to the coyote as one which chases, and this will be remembered by the coyote. Please do not let your dog get close to a coyote in the first place.

I am now seeing that the “chase-chase” behavior I have previously described — a behavior I have seen between a dog and coyote who have interacted negatively in the past — may actually be a coyote reconfirming and affirming her dominant status within an area: it could be seen as an infrequently used “reality check” for the dog — it constitutes a communication to a dog.  It is only the dominant female that I have ever seen engage in this kind of behavior: the dominant female is always the pack leader and the only reproducing female. I’ve never seen the behavior end in actual biting or harm — rather it seems to be an intense show to warn and inform dogs that have threatened the coyote in the past. I have seen this behavior only a few times.

Please keep your dog leashed and close to you in coyote areas. It is best to keep coyotes and dogs as far apart as possible. If you see a coyote, please head away from it and out of the area.  Few people know which is the alpha, and it is the alpha which is very protective of her “flock” and appears to be protective of her own “status”.

Looking Up To A Coyote Sibling and Sibling Curiosity

Of course, the pups in a family always look up to their mother. And she, the mother, leads and disciplines with care and firmness and affection. But when the mother is not around, or at least not close by, I’ve actually seen a hierarchy among the siblings. It’s less that there is a leader than that there is a follower, though I’ve seen the leader check on the other. The follower waits for, and looks up to the other sibling. I’m still seeing this behavior at one-year of age. Maybe this hierarchy is permanent? They BOTH constantly check on what the other is up to — there is always an immense curiosity and interest in this!

The leader is generally bolder and can be seen more often exploring on its own, or exploring just with the mother. The follower is much shyer and prefers not to be seen by people, flees quickly, and only hangs around if either the sibling or mother are there.

Next Newer Entries